Question : A proper land ownership ecology can be a major force to cull the menace of naxalism and radical left wing extremism. Examine. (200 words)
Answer : The growth of Leftwing Militant Radicalism, known in the official documents and civil society discussion as the Naxalite movement, has acquired considerable prominence in the public policy discourse, media coverage and interaction with the social scientists. The government’s policy to deal with it has also polarised thinking on how it should be understood and characterised and what would be the most appropriate approach to neutralise its influence. The security establishment and those supporting its view- point represent one pole of this intellectual divide, while the social scientists, activists and those engaged in working with and for the tribals constitute the other pole. The former group advocates strong police (armed) action to eliminate the ‘menace’ which is viewed as the greatest internal security threat to the country, while the latter group stresses on removing the root causes of alienation of the tribals by pursuing a comprehensive agenda of social justice, inclusive development and responsive governance which would end the influence of the Naxalities. The unaddressed grievances of the tribals, which have caused this alienation, those relating to alienation of their land, involuntary displacement, loss of forest rights are well documented in official reports as well as academic works.
The Way Forward
Question : Critically analyse the role of public private partnership in ensuring cyber security in India.(250 Words)
Answer : Role and Requirement of PPP in Ensuring Cyber Security
Question : Given the prevalence of sexist attitudes within the bureaucracy and police, an organizational response in terms of a common gender-neutral cadre is needed for better protection of women against crime. Analyze. (200 words)
Answer : A common gender-neutral cadre needs to be created for all ranks so that promotional opportunities are evenly available. Women should be routinely and readily considered for front-line postings at cutting edge levels based on their competence and experience. Resource centres for mentoring, creating awareness about opportunities and prospects, and helping with career planning and training and coping with workplace challenges are essential. Women have a role in making up for the lack of training and sensitisation of the force in general in dealing with crimes against women. At the same time, women constables and officers should not be ghettoized into dealing only with such crimes. As the experience in many countries of the world shows — New York City had its first policewoman as early as in 1845 — there is no policing function that women cannot perform. Given the prevalence of sexist attitudes within the bureaucracy and police, an organisational response from the force is needed to enable women to realise their full potential. The Ministry of Home Affairs should set targets for individual police forces and create a mechanism to monitor female advancement. Grants should be linked to progress achieved. Integrating women in the force should become an essential component of the process of police reform in India, enabling them to become real change agents. Having more women in the force should not be seen as just an expression of the formal fulfillment of sexual equality, important though that goal is. Rather, the contemporary needs of policing also demand it.
Question : The internal conflicts of India must be assessed and countered within a protracted-war paradigm, not the present and dominant emergency-response paradigm. Do you agree? Discuss supporting this proposition. (200 words)
Answer : India is a study in contrasts, if not contradictions. Extreme poverty and lack of opportunities coexist with rapid economic growth and obscene wealth, creating what commentators have often conceptualized as “two Indias.” These discrepancies, compounded by a wide range of external and internal destabilizers, produce enormous potential for discord as well as a number of enduring internal conflicts. The state’s responses to existing and emerging challenges of internal security have been marked by a high measure of incoherence, structural infirmities, and a growing crisis of capacities. Despite these deficits and vulnerabilities, India has extraordinary experience in defeating some of the most virulent insurgent and terrorist movements. Unfortunately, the lessons of successful counterinsurgency (CI) and counterterrorism (CT) campaigns have not been transferred efficiently to other theaters. While rapid economic growth has increased state resources, the policy environment remains crippled by the lack of a strategic culture and foresight. Nevertheless, there is increasing awareness of the urgency of a coherent strategic response. Ultimately, India’s political environment has demonstrated tremendous resilience, justifying the expectation that, in spite of its difficulties, the country will sustain its positive trajectory.
Policy Implications: A coherent policy framework is a precondition to the resolution of India’s internal security challenges.
Question : It is said that the present terrorism problem has emanated from the inefficiency of the UN. Critically comment. (250 words)
Answer : Recent events underscore the persistent and global nature of today's terrorist threat. Without question, transnational terrorism endangers international peace and security and therefore lies squarely under the UN's purview. No longer are groups such as Islamic States, al-Qaeda, the Taliban, Hizballah, Hamas, Lashkar-e-Taiba, and the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia focused solely on local issues; rather, their worldwide reach necessitates UN attention.
Question : Discuss the approach of the Government of India towards insurgency in the North Eastern parts of India taking into consideration the recent truce pact signed with the NSCN (IM) group? Also discuss the viability of these peace agreements to cull the menace of naxalism? (200 words)
Answer : The Government's approach is to deal with Left Wing Extremism in a holistic manner, in the areas of security, development, ensuring rights and entitlements of local communities, improvement in governance and public perception management. In dealing with this decades-old problem, it has been felt appropriate, after various high-level deliberations and interactions with the State Governments concerned, that an integrated approach (Integrated action plan) aimed at the relatively more affected areas would deliver results. With this in view, a detailed analysis of the spread and trends in respect of Left Wing Extremist violence has been made and 106 districts in nine States have been taken up for special attention with regard to planning, implementation and monitoring various interventions. However, 'Police' and 'Public Order' being State subjects, action on maintenance of law and order lies primarily in the domain of the State Governments. The Central Government closely monitors the situation and supplements and coordinates their efforts in several ways. These include providing Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs) and Commando Battalions for Resolute Action (CoBRA); sanction of India Reserve (IR) battalions, setting up of Counter Insurgency and Anti-Terrorism (CIAT) schools; modernisation and upgradation of the State Police and their Intelligence apparatus under the Scheme for Modernization of State Police Forces (MPF scheme); re-imbursement of security related expenditure under the Security Related Expenditure (SRE) Scheme; filling up critical infrastructure gaps under the Scheme for Special Infrastructure in Left Wing Extremism affected States; providing helicopters for anti-naxal operations, assistance in training of State Police through the Ministry of Defence, the Central Police Organisations and the Bureau of Police Research and Development; sharing of Intelligence; facilitating inter-State coordination; assistance in community policing and civic action programmes etc. The underlying philosophy is to enhance the capacity of the State Governments to tackle the Maoist menace in a concerted manner. The Division also monitors the implementation of Integrated Action Plan for LWE affected Districts (now called Additional Central Assistance to LWE affected districts) and various other development and infrastructure initiatives of Govt. of India.
Question : "Threat posed by ISIS to India's internal security can be dealt through concerted security related actions". Critically analyze the word 'concerted' in the aforesaid statement. (200 words)
Answer : ISIS is a group which wants to spread its empire to the entire world and take the fight to the very end of days. To full-fill its ambition, it will surely have to confront India as India poses a challenge to it, both ideologically and geopolitically.
Also, India has a large population of Muslims who have always acted as an example against the radical ways of the terrorist organisation. Even though people have joined these groups in large numbers from the western countries, Indian Muslims have not only refrained but have actively voiced against such groups. ISIS would surely want to break this trend and induce radicalism in India. "Though joining the fight against ISIS would benefit its image globally, as an active participant in world affairs and help it cement its seat in UNSC, the war may take heavy toll on it, both financially and in terms of manpower. Even a power like USA could not finish affairs in Afghanistan despite heavy spending. Also, it would act as an active invitation to ISIS to turn its full attention to India. So, for the time, country should repose faith in its minority and just wait and watch.
To tackle these problems the following suggestions are made.
The immunity and insularity of Indian youth from international extremist vagaries is robust and time-tested. The mutual cooperation between government and citizens further cements this belief and augments internal security and external safe outlook. The proper confidence building approach is required for coordination between all security officials like IB, RAW and NIA etc.
Question : "Border management has multiple challenges and one of them being achievement of co-ordination among various security agencies involved." In the light of this statement, would you recommend a single security force for managing the entire land border of India? (200 words)
Answer : The proper management of borders is vitally important for national security. Different portions of our extensive borders have a variety of problems specific to them which have to be appropriately addressed. These problems have become aggravated in recent times with Pakistan's policy of cross- border terrorism, along with its intensely hostile anti-India propaganda designed to mislead and sway the loyalties of the border population. The intensification of cross-border terrorism, targeted to destabilize India, has thrown up new challenges for our border management policy.
Development of Integrated Check Posts: Brief on Integrated Check Posts (Icps)
Question : "21st century has witnessed a revolution in information and communication technology." How has this development in means of communication posed challenges for internal security?(200 words)
Answer : In cutthroat competition and rapidly changing technical environment, there is more economic uncertainty and complexities affecting the nation. Currently, security has imperative role to protect data and relevant and secret information from growing internet attacks on computing and communication systems with the support of continuous innovative solutions. It is therefore necessary to provide a means for researchers in this domain to encourage quality publications of their work. Security is described by experts as ensuring protected communication among computing/communication systems and user applications across public and private networks, is essential for guaranteeing confidentiality, privacy and data/information protection.
Question : India has a long coastline which makes it vulnerable to various security hazards. How are our coastal borders guarded against anti-state elements and what changes have been brought in this context after 2008? (200 words)
Answer : Some facts
Initiatives: With the coordinated efforts of all the concerned security forces and related departments the government has placed adequate measures to gear up overall maritime security much stronger than pre 2008 attacks.
Conclusion: Since 2008, coastal and maritime security has been strengthened substantially by successful implementation of technical, organisational and procedural initiatives, by all maritime security agencies. Plugging gaps, where identified, is continuous process that is being addressed appropriately.
Question : Discuss the methods used by terrorist organizations to raise finances for funding their inhumane operations and also discuss global response to curb their finances. (250 Words)
Answer : They derive funding from variety of criminal activities:
Global Response
What is required to be done?
Question : Explain how organized crime can be linked with terrorism? And do you think organized crime supports terrorism in India? Justify giving suitable examples. (250 Words)
Answer : Crime and terrorism can potentially have a very close linkage. While there may or may not always be a linkage between the two, however, both international case studies and those in India do point towards it. If we look at some of the regions in the country affected by terrorism, this linkage becomes apparent. In the Northeast, extortion is the fundamental basis for funding all forms of terrorism. In addition to this, kidnapping has been used extensively for spreading terror and raising funds. Human trafficking, drug trafficking and gun running are some of the other criminal activities that have been common in these areas.
Question : Can India's aspiration of becoming a 'blue-water' naval force viable in the current geopolitical scenario? Discuss. (200 words)
Answer : Once India's former Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru had said "To be safe on land, we must be supreme at sea". Much has been said about the Indian Navy's blue water aspirations over time. However a number of experts have already described the Indian Navy as being a blue-water navy and the intentions of developing blue-water capabilities were outlined under the 2007 Maritime Capabilities Perspective Plan. In the recent times India has built one of the largest and most powerful navies in the world with an indication towards major possibilities of further growth. It has 2 conventional Aircraft carriers, 1 amphibious transport dock, 50 Frigates, Destroyers and Corvettes one nuclear-powered and14 conventionally-powered attack submarines and a many other naval ships including around 100 armed patrol ships with the Indian Coast Guards.
Why Blue Water Capabilities?
Question : Cyber space is the new domain of war emerging in modern times. Is India prepared to defend itself in cyber space? If not, suggest some measures to defend India's cyber space. (200 words)
Answer : Cyberspace as an independent theatre of war is about attacks that compromise the capability to use these facilities: they cannot be prevented by the security services in isolation.
As a Weapon: Cyber-attacks are already happening daily, and, as we are getting more and more 'connected' the threats also becoming more complex. Symantec, a leading international cyber security company, recorded that in 2010 alone there were three billion malware attacks. Of these one stands out especially, pointing to the possible use by legitimate governments of cyber weapons. This was the case of Stuxnet, which attacked five Iranian organisations, all reportedly connected with their uranium enrichment and nuclear programmes.In those cases, the United States is the likely suspect, but though nothing can be conclusively established, China has consistently topped the list of official suspects in the world of cyber-attacks.
India's Response System: There are no easy responses to all these phenomena. The U.S. has created CYBERCOM in 2009 as a military command dedicated to cyber warfare. In the civilian arena few countries have a credible equivalent.
Proactive policy: There is only one part of the IDSA Task Force's recommendations with which I have a difference of emphasis. It speaks about "proactive diplomatic policy" on cyber security, and suggests that multilateral efforts for international internet governance are useful. The Report itself recognises that most proposals for international internet governance are thinly masked efforts to control or shape the internet, and that some are ideologically driven. Inter-governmental rules of the road are certainly desirable. No one can argue against them. But we must be clear that they will not have practical effect or be followed unless they are in the clear self-interest of those who should be following them. Let us, therefore, concentrate on putting our own cyber security house in order. That should be our first priority.
Question : Discuss the stand of Indian government with respect to disarmament of nuclear weapons. Also make a case for the global disarmament of the nuclear weapons considering ongoing geopolitical conflicts. (200 words)
Answer : We do not believe that a nuclear war should be fought and we do not believe that a nuclear war can be won.
Atal Bihari Vajpayee: Disarmament initiatives have been an important element of India's foreign policy from the beginning. For instance, in 1954 India under Nehru's leadership was the first country to propose an agreement to ban nuclear weapons tests, which ultimately culminated in 1963 in the Treaty Banning Nuclear Tests in the Atmosphere, in Outer Space and Under Water (Partial Test Ban Treaty) (PTBT). Though this was only a partial triumph, Nehru was rightly recognized for his leadership of the global campaign that led to the PTBT. Even as he remained opposed to weaponization, Nehru's vision of India's future did involve the robust use of nuclear science and technology for peaceful purposes. Historically, some of the country's most accomplished diplomats have been associated with India's disarmament diplomacy. Although India took the lead in many of these issues, it nevertheless found itself at a disadvantage in many cases, most obviously with regard to the 1968 Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT). India chose to stay out of the NPT regime and in the years that followed, there was perhaps an unstated shift of policy from nuclear abolition to ambiguity. Two important moments in the 1990s mark a watershed in India's long association with arms control and disarmament: rejection of the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty (CTBT) in 1996, and the overt weaponisation of India's nuclear deterrent in 1998.
Question : For National Security, a sense of belonging and nationhood is necessary. Discuss. (200 words)
Answer : Answer can be framed on the following lines:
Question : The rise of ISIL poses a grave threat to India. Discuss it with proper arguments based on geo-political dimensions and recent developments?
Answer : The Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS), also sometimes referred to as the Al-Tawhid or the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) is a militant jihadist outfit predominantly active in Iraq and Syria. The main ambition of the group is to create a united, transnational pan-Islamic state, a sharia-based caliphate, stretching mainly across Iraq and the Levant region. This includes parts of Syria, Israel, Jordon, Lebanon, Egypt, south Turkey, and the Palestinian territories. The foundations of the ISIS can be found in the aftermath of the US-led invasion of Iraq, when this offshoot of the al-Qaida in Iraq (AQI) formed its agenda to promote insurgency in the region through guerrilla warfare. Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi is the newly named Caliph of the Islamic State formed by the ISIS. In the recent time Iraq has been in on the verge of a civil war due to this challenge posed by the ISIS.
ISIS a threat to India: At first look it may seem that apart from concerns over fate of the nationals in Iraq, India is not at immediate threat from the ISIS. The group only seems keen on carving out a caliphate along the Iraqi-Syrian border and in the Middle East. A closer look, however, reveals that the threat is a more imminent one. ISIS has global ambitions which include carving out an Islamic World Dominion. India will be a prime threat in the achievement of these ambitions.
Strategy for tackling the threat: Tackling this threat requires a new security strategy. Government of India must seek to forge an anti-terror coalition against ISIL and other jihadi threats emanating from the Middle East and North Africa region. Countries such as Morocco have been deploying interesting anti-terror strategies including fighting extremism through moderate theology. With reports emerging of Indians having travelled to Iraq and Syria to fight alongside ISIL, such strategies are worth exploring in addition to hardnosed security measures. Also, establishing security links with West Asian and North African countries through the platform of South-South cooperation needs to be taken up on a priority basis.
Question : Growing development deficit and regional disparities are major cause of concern for the growing militancy in India. Critically discuss. (200 words)
Answer : Economic liberalization which began in the early 1990s has accelerated India’s growth rate to an average of 7% per year since 1997, up from 3.5% in the 1970s. During this period India transformed itself from an agricultural economy to a service economy. Services now form 55% of the Indian economy. The growth and development of the Information Technology and Information Technology enabled Services have had a significant role in changing the face of the economy. The good news does not end here. The growth rate for India is expected to overtake China’s double digit growth rate in the next few years.
This news however, hides some alarming trends. Growth continues to bypass a large section of people. A large majority of Indians live in the villages and they have been excluded from India’s growth story. Rural India is facing endemic problems – land holdings are shrinking, slow growth in agricultural production and limited social and economic infrastructure. Women, Children, backward castes & classes and other minorities often are excluded from the growth story. The rise of grass root militant movements which plague nearly one-tenth of India is a direct result of this economic exclusion and the unfulfilled aspirations of the bottom billion.
The following problems are the major concerns for developing countries like India to achieve the inclusive growth. They are:
India has been endowed with some of the world’s most essential minerals, beautiful places, diverse cultures and capable and talented people. It is time we stop squandering this advantage and make the most of what most countries can never even dream to have. There is much to be done, but if done and done correctly then nothing can stop us from reaching the pinnacle of the world.
SUGGESTIONS
Question : Naxal problem does not require air-power. Discuss
Answer : The debate on the use or non-use of certain forces has centred on the fear of collateral damage, to the total exclusion of the psychological impact of the Naxal affected area. The air element has a great psychological effect on the adversary as it can raise the morale of our own forces while lowering that of the adversary.
The battle has to be fought on five fronts simultaneously: Economic, political, psychological, social, and military. Use of force is thus only one of the fronts, and to be successful it has to be in consonance with the other four. This has to be clear right at the outset. That does not mean force is unimportant. In fact, in order to get the other measures and strategies in place, control over violence is a pre-requisite.
Question : Bring out the differences in the nature and causes of the challenge to internal security in the North Eastern States of India and Jammu and Kashmir.
Answer : Nature and Causes of North East Insurgency
Insurgency in Jammu & Kashmir: The insurgency in Kashmir or the Kashmiri Insurgency is an internal conflict between Kashmiri insurgents and the Government of India. Some of the insurgents favor Kashmiri accession to Pakistan, while others seek Kashmir's complete independence. Since 2002, skirmishes with the local insurgents have constituted the main conflict in the Kashmir region.
Question : Discuss the challenges of managing cyber space from a national security perspective. In this regard make a critical assessment of National Cyber Security Policy 2013.
Answer : India’s cyber security scenario is that India ranks 3rd in terms of the highest number of Internet users in the world after USA and China but at the same time India secures a spot amongst the top 10 spam-sending countries in the world alongside USA.
Protection of information and information infrastructure is now a key factor to our national security and the four binding pillars of information security i.e. Confidentiality, Integrity, Availability and Non-repudiation are the prerequisite to achieve it. Confidentiality is among the key factors especially in relation to defence systems and the emphasis is always on strong crypto-logical i.e. encryption systems.
Critical assessment of National Cyber Security Policy 2013
Question : Discuss the role of various non-State actors operating in India’s neighbour and posing a threat to its internal peace.
Answer : India’s internal security landscape in recent decades has undergone a paradigm shift. The conventional pattern of civil disorders, communal disturbances, social and economic turmoil, political conflicts etc. have seized to be the nation’s primary internal security concerns. They have been substituted by externally sponsored covert offensives by hostile powers targeting country’s internal fault lines to achieve their strategic objectives. While country’s democratic polity, economic growth, and social transformations are steadily bringing down conventional threats, except probably the Left Wing Extremism, the external factor has been an important catalytic factor in promoting terrorism, insurgencies, espionage, subversion, cyber space violations, currency counterfeiting, Hawala transactions, demographic invasion etc. India considering its Comprehensive National Power (CNP), has failed is politically and diplomatically leverage it to its best security advantage.
Question : Proper and equitable coverage of State media is necessary for maintaining security in the border regions. Discuss
Answer : Media is the most powerful tool of communication. It helps promoting the right things on right time. It gives a real exposure to the mass audience about what is right or wrong. Even though media is linked with spreading fake news like a fire, but on the safe side, it helps a lot to inform us about the realities as well. Media, the means of communication that reaches or influences people widely has a significant place in the statecraft machinery especially in the age of information revolution.
Question : Some form of restriction on internet and cyberspace is necessary for maintaining internal security in a diverse nation like India. Do you agree? Discuss the same considering some of the most recent happenings?
Answer : The use of the internet for raising money, propagate terror ideology and engineer recruitment is another significant aspect of modern day terrorism. The internet is widely used for purposes of propaganda, recruitment, information, and intelligence. It has become like a virtual sanctuary for cell based terrorism which is not territorially bound like the al Qaeda. Terror handbooks, videos, and propaganda are uploaded into the internet for wide dissemination and publicity. Websites carry the message of terror groups to a wider audience and generate funds and recruits to their cause. Terrorists are also increasingly using the internet chat rooms to “share information, coordinate attacks, spread propaganda, raise funds, and recruit. The use of the internet serves the purpose of terrorist groups because they operate in small cells and are not based in a single geographical area. Hence, for operational planning, the internet, satellite and mobile phones are being used extensively. This easy communication through the internet brings in the transnational character of terrorism. Terrorists can be anywhere and yet stay wired using technology. Even during attacks, the leader of a particular terror attack can give instructions via satellite phone. During the Mumbai attacks in 2008, the 10 LeT men broke up into small teams and were in touch with each other through the cell phone devices like Blackberries. They used the Global Positioning System (GPS) to steer their boat towards Mumbai. During the attacks at the Taj Hotel, the terrorists were continuously being instructed via satellite phone by their Pakistan based controllers.
Question : What are the impacts made by “OPERATION STEEPLECHASE and OPERATION BARGA” in culling the Naxalbari movement in West Bengal? What lessons do they provide for policy makers in the present context?
Answer : OPERATION STEEPLECHASE- Naxalism gets its name from May 1967’s peasant uprising at Naxalbari in Darjeeling, West Bengal, which led to the founding of the CPI (Marxist-Leninist). It still thrives in the new avatar of Left-wing extremism. It started when three sharecroppers lifted 300 mounds of paddy from the granary of a jotedar with the support of 150 CPI (M) workers armed with lathis, bows and arrows. The initial dithering of the authorities added momentum to the Naxalite movement, which lasted 52 days before the state came down heavily on the radicals, killing 20 of them. With the Chinese communist newspaper, People’s Daily, eulogising it as “spring thunder” over India, the movement spread to new areas in other states. While sustained and strong police action kept it under check in West Bengal, the release of the Naxalite leaders after the CPI (M) tasted power at the ballot for the first time in 1969, gave the movement a fresh lease of life. On May Day in 1969, Sanyal announced the birth of CPI (ML). In July 1971, however the government mobilised the Indian Army against the Naxalites and launched a colossal combined army and police counter-insurgency operation, termed "Operation Steeplechase," killing hundreds of Naxalites and imprisoning more than 20,000 suspects and cadres, including senior leaders. The paramilitary forces and a brigade of para commandos also participated in Operation Steeplechase.
OPERATION BARGA- Operation Barga was a land reform movement throughout rural West Bengal for recording the names of sharecroppers (bargadars) while avoiding the time-consuming method of recording through the settlement machinery. It bestowed on the bargadars, the legal protection against eviction by the landlords, and entitled them to the due share of the produce. Operation Barga was launched in 1978 and concluded by the mid-1980s. Introduced in 1978, and given legal backing in 1979 and 1980, Operation Barga became a popular but controversial measure for land reforms. The ultimate aim of these land reforms was to facilitate the conversion of the state's bargadars into landowners, in line with the Directive Principles of State Policy of the Indian Constitution (Art. 34). To date, Op Barga has recorded the names of approximately 1.5 million bargadars. Since then, it has been marked as one of the more successful land reforms programs in India.
Question : Discuss the linkages between terrorism and organised crimes in Indian society?
Answer : Organized crime and terrorism result from ineffective governance and have developed a symbiotic relationship; nevertheless, it is essential to differentiate them. Neither are all terrorist acts organized crime, nor are all organized criminal acts terrorism; in most developed countries, organized crime thrives with little or no terrorist activities, and in most developing countries, terrorism exists along with varying levels of organized criminal activity.
Question : What were the salient features of the guidelines issued in 1972 regarding land ceiling and how far the guidelines have been effective?
Answer : The important objectives of land reform measures in India were:
On the recommendation of Central Land Reforms Committee, Government of India issued a guideline in 1972 which was a follows:
Question : Discuss the various provisions of Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act 1996. Do you think that this legislation has potential of containing naxalism in scheduled areas?
Answer : Provisions of Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act 1996
PESA Act 1996 has a great potential to wipe out Naxal violence, preserve forests and ecology, and to assimilate 8 crore tribal into the national mainstream. But state governments lack will power to implement the PESA act honestly.
The main hurdle in the proper implementation of PESA comes from the nexus of bureaucrats and politicians who would lose authority in tribal areas. They have always subordinated the welfare of poor tribals in favor of the rich or the powerful. Giving real autonomy to Gram Sabhas, as envisioned in the Act, would leave them without much influence.
Economic liberalization has brought the corporate giants into the region hunting for minerals for their mega size industrial exploits. Industry is wreaking havoc with the living conditions of the tribals under the liberalization regime. Their acts force the helpless tribals to leave the land they have known to be their own since ages. Compensation and rehabilitation plans are hardly ever implemented with honesty and dignity.
Looking at the performance of State governments in implementation of PESA and their tendency to by-pass it, the Central government should issue a notification that all other laws will be subordinate to PESA in the fifth schedule (or PESA) areas.
PESA has the real potential to deal a fatal blow to the leftwing extremists thriving on their backwardness, ignorance, and isolation. The “Original Indian People” of India deserve a life free of exploitation, poverty, and fear.
Question : What are the important reasons which have led to increase in crimes against women? Suggest effective steps needed to prevent such crimes.
Answer : Women are soft targets and most of the cases instituted have not been properly investigated.
Effective steps needed to prevent crime against women
Question : What are the potential threats from ‘cybercrime’? Do you think our police machinery is equipped to deal with such crimes?
Answer : Potential Threats from 'Cyber Crimes'
There are many drawbacks which prevent cybercrimes from being solved in India. Firstly, most people in India prefer not to report cybercrimes to the law enforcement agencies because they fear it might invite a lot of harassment. Secondly, awareness of cybercrime is extremely low. Thirdly, the law enforcement agencies in the country are not well equipped and knowledgeable enough about cybercrime. “There is an immense need for training the law enforcement agencies. Very few cities have cybercrime cells. Under the IT Act, the relevant officer entitled to investigate a cybercrime is a deputy superintendent of police, but most DSPs are not well equipped to fight cybercrime. “There is a need for dedicated, continuous, updated training of the law enforcement agencies. There is also a lack of dedicated cybercrime courts in the country where expertise in cybercrime can be utilized. The problem is that awareness of people about cybercrime is still very low and so we need to take many steps to invigorate the legal scenario. There is a need for a distinct law on cybercrime and appropriate changes should be made in the Indian Penal Code and the Information Technology Act. “Uniform guidelines on cyber forensic tools and strategies should be circulated among investigating officers of cybercrime in the country. There is also a need to expedite cybercrime trials. We further need to learn constantly from the ever-growing developments in cybercrime all across the world.
Question : What are the salient features of Armed Forces (Special Power) Act, 1958? What safeguards are needed to ensure that armed forces do not abuse the power and protection granted under the Act?
Answer : Salient Features of Armed Forces (Special Power) Act 1958
Safeguard Needed
Question : What do you understand by ‘organized crime’? Do you think that ‘Maharashtra Control of Organized Crime Act, 1999 (MCOCA)’ is an effective law to deal with such crimes?
Answer : Maharashtra Control of Organized Crime Act 1999. (MCOCA) defines organized crime as any continuing unlawful activity by an individual, or in group, by use of violence or other unlawful means with the objective of gaining any benefit or advantage for himself, or any other person or promoting insurgency. Organized crime includes extortion, kidnapping for ransom, gunrunning, money laundering.
Under MCOCA
Question : If any historical dispute is not solved and reconciled completely than it is bound to repeat. Bring the justification of this while you discuss the territorial disputes of North Eastern states? (200 words)
Answer : An ongoing separatist struggle has continued in the region since the late 1940s, making it the longest running separatist struggle in South Asia. There are multiple parties involved in the struggles including different ethnic groups and states, some of whom want total independence from India while others call for a restructuring of the states.
Question : Discuss the origin of ‘Assam Rifles’ and the historic role played by it.
Answer : The Assam Rifles created in 1835 is the oldest Central Para Military force. The force was raised in the background of protecting the Assam plains against the unruly tribes inhabited around the area. The force is also known as “sentinels of the North – East” and “Friends of the Hill people”.
Question : What was the purpose of creation of Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)? Suggest how it could be provided with ‘functional autonomy’.
Answer : CBI derives power to investigate from the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946. Section 2 of the Act vests DSPE with jurisdiction to investigate offences in the Union Territories only. However, the jurisdiction can be extended by the Central Government to other areas including Railway areas and States under Section 5(1) of the Act, provided the State Government accords consent under Section 6 of the Act. The executive officers of CBI of the rank of Sub Inspector and above exercise all powers of a station office in-charge of the police station for the concerned area for the purpose of investigation. As per Section 3 of the Act, Special Police Establishment is authorised to investigate only those cases, which are notified by the Central Government from time to time.
Suggestions for CBI with Functional Autonomy
The officers for the cadre of CBI it was suggested that the present system of having a mix of permanent cadre along with officers on deputation can be continued with modification that the CBI Director be allowed to induct officer till the rank of S.P. and not till inspectors. It will allow the officers from CBI cadre to man the top positions in the CBI and the involvement of officers on deputation from the states would ensure active participation of state police machinery in investigation in different states.
The next suggestion is that long pending demand of CBI to have its own panel of lawyers thereby giving it greater autonomy, especially in politically-sensitive investigations. Also, the following proposal of Central Government made in the affidavit before the Supreme Court, were:
Question : Briefly discuss some of the state and non-state actors involved in various terrorist activities in India and the role of Pakistan in their training and providing logistic support
Answer : Pakistan poses the most serious threat to India's national security. India's unresolved issues with Pakistan are well known like Kashmir, Siachen, Afghanistan and the nuclear issue.
Question : Separation of Law and Order work from Investigation
Answer : Under the ambit of new police reforms, investigation of cases has been separated from law and order, security and other duties, which will improve overall performance of police in the province. Other advantages are:
Question : National Investigation Agency (NIA)
Answer : A Bill for the formation of the National Investigation Agency was passed by Parliament in December 2008. As per the Bill, NIA has concurrent jurisdiction which empowers the Centre to probe terror attacks in any part of the country, covering offences, including challenge to the country's sovereignty and integrity, bomb blasts, hijacking of aircraft and ships, and attacks on nuclear installations.
Mission of NIA:
Question : Rapid Action Force (RAF)
Answer : The increasing communal tensions and riots during the early nineties had been putting a serious strain on the secular structure of Indian Society. Consequently the Government took a well-considered decision to set up a special anti-riot force which could reach the place of occurrence with the quickest possible speed and deal with communal riot or riot-like situation in an absolutely objective and non-partisan manner.
Question : Border Security Force (BSF)
Answer : Till 1965 India’s borders with Pakistan were manned by the State Armed Police Battalion. As a result of the recommendations of the Committee of Secretaries, the Border Security Force came into existence on 01 Dec 1965, and Shri K.F. Rustamji was the first chief and founding father.
The tasks of the BSF are divided as follows:
1. Peace Time:
2. War Time:
Question : Special Protection Group (SPG)
Answer : SPG is responsible for the protection of the Prime Ministers, former Prime Ministers and their immediate family members. The force was established in 1985 after the assassination of Indira Gandhi. It provides proximate security to protectees, including protection provided from close quarters, journey on foot, road, rail, aircraft, watercraft or any other means of transport, and includes places of functions, engagements, residence, etc.
Question : National Disaster Response Force
Answer : Constituted by upgradation/conversion of 8 battalions of CPMF and CISF. These battalions have been presently stationed at eight judiciously selected places.These units will work under the general Superintendence, direction and control of NDMA. States have also been advised to setup their own Specialized Response Teams.
Question : Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP)
Answer : Indo-Tibetan Border Police was conceived on October 24, 1962. ITBP was initially raised under the CRPF Act, however in 1992, the parliament enacted the ITBPF Act and rules there under were framed in 1994.
ITBP is a multidimensional force. Presently Battalions of ITBP deployed on Border Guarding Duties from Karakoram Pass in Ladakh to Jelep La in Arunachal Pradesh covering 3488 KM of India China Border are manning Border Out-Posts at an altitude ranging from 9000’ to 18500’ in the Western, Middle & Eastern Sector of India China Border.
Functions & Tasks:
Question : Why Cyber security has become significant for India. Examine the controversy regarding section 66A of IT Act, 2008.
Answer : Since 1990, India has been the victim of cyber-attacks from Pakistan and China. There are increasing evidences of resources being taken by terrorists to the cyberspace domain. In early March 2013, suspected Chinese hackers breached the computers of India's top military organisation, the DRDO. India faced a severe test of its cyber security during the 2010 Commonwealth games when cyber-attacks from Pakistan and China sought to damage information systems.
India has the following Cyber threats:
Section 66A of IT Act, 2008 provides for punishment for sending offensive messages through communication services. This provision is widely held by legal experts to be unconstitutional as it violates freedom of speech guaranteed by article 19(1) of the Constitution.
Question : What are the main factors that determine foreign investment in a country? Why China is a better investment destination than India?
Question : Mention the main features of State Armed Police Forces and their role in maintaining internal security in India?
Answer : The State Armed Police Forces are organisations which provide the state with policing in particularly violent or serious situations. Such forces are often involved with combating banditry and Naxalites. Like the Central Armed Police Forces, they are sometimes known unofficially as "paramilitary forces".
Question : What do you mean by effective revenue deficit? Why does amended FRBM Act aim at bringing down effective revenue deficit to zero level rather than the revenue deficit?
Answer : Revenue deficit is the difference between expenditure on revenue account of the budget and receipts on the revenue account of the budget. Effective revenue deficit is equal to revenue deficit minus capital grants by the central government to states or PSUs.
Question : What are the main reasons of low productivity in Indian agriculture? Enumerate the measures taken by the government to enhance agricultural productivity.
Answer : Both the poorest as well as the more prosperous ‘Green Revolution’ states of Punjab, Haryana, Andhra Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh have recently witnessed a slow-down in agricultural growth and it ultimately led to farmer’s suicide. Some of the reasons for low growth are:
Steps taken by the government are:
Question : What is the role of National Investigation Agency in maintaining security of India?
Answer : It acts as the Central Counter Terrorism Law Enforcement Agency. The agency is empowered to deal with terror related crimes across states without special permission from the states.
Question : Near Field Communication or NFC
Answer : Near field communication (NFC) is a set of standards for smart phones and similar devices to establish radio communication with each other by touching them together or bringing them into close proximity, usually no more than a few inches.
Question : Write notes on the Border Area Development Programme (BADP)
Answer : The Department of Border Management was created in MHA in January 2004 to pay focused attention to the issues relating to management of international land and coastal borders, especially the internal security aspect.
Question : Write notes on the Sagar Prahari Bal
Question : Write notes on the National Intelligence Grid (NATGRID)
Question : Write notes on the Operation Green Hunt
Answer : Operation Green Hunt describes the operation launched by Government of India's paramilitary forces and the state's forces against the Naxalites in Red Corridor.
Question : Write notes on the Structure and functions of the Indian Coast Guard.
Question : Write notes on the Functions of Special Protection Group.
Answer : The Special Protection Group (SPG) is the executive protection agency of the Government of India.
Question : Write notes on the Special Frontier Force (SFF)
Answer : It was created on 14th November, 1962, near the end of Indo-China war. Its main goal was to conduct covert operations behind the Chinese lines in the event of another Indo-China war. Its headquarters is in Chakrata, 100 km from Dehradun.